Background: Alpha-feto-protein producing gastric adenocarcinoma is a rare and aggressive subtype of gastric cancer, associated with poor prognosis. Case Presentation: We report the case of a 66-year-old female with a history of hypertension and hypothyroidism who presented with severe anemia and abdominal pain. Initial imaging revealed a gastric lesion. Serum Alfa-Fetoprotein (AFP) was requested due to a suspicious lesion seen on initial liver imaging, and it was markedly elevated (>9000 ng/mL), raising suspicion for AFP-producing gastric cancer versus liver infarction due to venous thrombosis. Endoscopic biopsy of the gastric lesion confirmed Enteroblastic gastric adenocarcinoma. Subsequent MRI abdomen demonstrated hypermetabolic activity in the gastric lesion and in the abdominal lymph nodes without distant metastasis. Given her frailty and reluctance to undergo intravenous chemotherapy, she was offered oral chemotherapy (Capecitabine). Conclusion: Here, we present a case of AFP- producing gastric adenocarcinoma, a rare tumor that has not previously been reported from the Middle Eastern region, to the best of our current knowledge.